Too Many Cooks or Too Few: Collaboration vs. Chaos

lcome to the final episode in our “Pre-Production Pitfalls” series! Victoria and Chuck report live from the chaotic trenches of filmmaking. Over the last few episodes, they've been spilling the tea on many hard-earned lessons, and today’s dish is all about the sweet spot of crew management and film collaboration: how to avoid a kitchen overrun with cooks or a ship with no sailors.

The Goldilocks Crew: Not Too Big, Not Too Small, Just Right

Every filmmaker dreams of a well-oiled crew that runs like clockwork. Reality? You’re more likely to end up with either a skeleton team pulling quadruple duty or a bloated brigade tripping over each other (and their egos). Chuck recalls one indie set where everyone, including the lead actor, doubled as caterer, while Victoria vividly remembers a national commercial shoot with 500 extras and enough crew to rival a Marvel movie. Spoiler alert: neither extreme is ideal.

Lesson #1: Tailor your crew size to your project’s needs. Small indie shoot? Keep it lean to avoid unnecessary chaos. Big-budget spectacle? Bring in the troops but make sure they have clearly defined roles—and no one’s just there for the craft services.

Stay in Your Lane (But Keep an Eye on the Map)

Ah, the classic debate: should everyone stick strictly to their job titles, or is collaboration king? Victoria’s take? Collaboration rules, but accountability is key. Chuck learned this the hard way when his behind-the-camera instincts kicked in during an acting gig. After a gentle reminder to “stay in his lane,” he couldn’t resist pointing out a tripod creeping into the shot. Turns out, sometimes stepping out of your lane saves the day.

Lesson #2: Assign clear responsibilities, but foster a collaborative environment where anyone can speak up with a great idea or to catch a mistake. Just don’t let “It’s not my job” become the mantra.

Volunteer World: Blessing and Curse

In indie filmmaking, you’re often working with volunteers. Great for the budget, tricky for consistency. Chuck recounts sets where extra hands were more hassle than help. Victoria’s advice? Don’t drag people to set unless they’re genuinely needed. And if your leads are also fetching lunch? Maybe rethink your priorities.

Lesson #3: Respect your team’s time and talents. Overstaffing leads to idle hands and frustration; understaffing creates burnout. Find the balance.

Experts Are Worth Their Weight in Gold

Let’s talk specialists. Whether it’s a production designer who transforms a set or a makeup artist who trains actors to DIY their looks, the right expert can elevate your project from amateur to professional. Chuck raves about his DP-slash-gaffer who lit up scenes like magic, while Victoria swears by her makeup artist’s ability to craft cracked porcelain doll effects for a theater production.

Lesson #4: Invest in the right people for pivotal roles. A skilled production designer or makeup artist can save time, reduce stress, and make your project look top-notch.

Intimacy & Respect: Know When to Slim the Crew

For sensitive scenes—like the shower moment Victoria shot with a single actor in a cramped bathroom—less is more. A skeleton crew (with the rest watching via Video Village) ensured respect and comfort. Intimacy coordinators are also becoming the norm for good reason.

Lesson #5: Create a respectful, minimal environment for vulnerable scenes. Your cast will thank you.

It’s About the Who, Not the How Many for Film Collaboration

Ultimately, it’s not about hitting a magic number for crew size—it’s about assembling the right team. A harmonious crew that communicates and collaborates can do wonders, while one bad apple can spoil the whole production. Chuck likens it to being in a band: would you rather have a technically perfect guitarist or one who’s creative, collaborative, and fun to work with? (Hint: pick the latter.)

Lesson #6: Prioritize personality and teamwork over sheer skill. A cohesive team trumps an ego-driven superstar every time.

Final Thoughts: Just Start Shooting

If there’s one thing Victoria and Chuck want you to take away, it’s this: don’t let crew logistics stop you from making your film. Whether you’re a two-person team juggling cameras and lav mics or running a massive operation with a megaphone-toting AD, the important thing is to get out there and create.

And with that, we bid farewell to our “Pre-Production Pitfalls” series. Catch you on the next episode, diving into the glorious chaos of production! Until then, may your sets be productive, your crews be kind, and your snacks be plentiful. Cheers!

Subscribe on YouTube