Post-Production Mistakes Indie Films Make (And Why “Fix It in Post” Rarely Works)

“We’ll fix it in post.” It’s one of the most common phrases in indie filmmaking, and one of the most dangerous.

Post-production is often treated like a safety net, a place where lighting issues, audio problems, and unclear story choices can magically be repaired. But in reality, post-production tends to expose mistakes, not erase them. Many indie films don’t fail because of budget limitations, they fall apart because of post-production mistakes that compound late in the process.

In this episode of Indie Film Podcast, we take an honest look at the post-production mistakes indie filmmakers make, why they happen so often, and what actually separates inexpensive films from ones that just feel cheap.

“Fix It in Post” Is One of the Most Common Indie Film Mistakes

The phrase “fix it in post” isn’t always wrong, but it’s frequently misunderstood.

Post-production can:

• enhance intentional choices

• refine pacing and tone

• clean up small technical issues

What it can’t do is fix:

• poor lighting decisions

• inconsistent audio capture

• unclear story structure

• coverage gaps

One of the biggest post-production mistakes indie filmmakers make is assuming that editing, color grading, or audio plugins can compensate for decisions that should have been made earlier in production.

Color Grading Mistakes That Make Indie Films Look Cheap

Color grading is often where indie filmmakers expect a miracle, and where disappointment sets in. A LUT cannot fix your poor lighting choices. If you take nothing else away from this episode, we hope you at least walk away with that!

Common color grading mistakes in indie film include:

• relying on LUTs to “fix” bad lighting

• mismatched cameras with no plan to normalize footage

• flattening contrast instead of shaping depth

• pushing exposure or color too far to compensate for underlit scenes

Color grading works best when it supports lighting choices made on set, not when it’s used to rescue them. If your footage lacks contrast, motivation, or consistency, post-production can only take you so far.

Audio Post-Production Mistakes Indie Filmmakers Overlook

Nothing makes an indie film feel cheap faster than bad audio.

Some of the most common indie film audio mistakes happen during post-production:

• inconsistent dialogue levels between shots

• overly aggressive noise reduction

• ADR that doesn’t match the original mic, distance, or space

• missing room tone or ambience

Clean audio isn’t the same as believable audio. Post-production audio work should focus on matching reality, not erasing it. When dialogue feels disconnected from the environment, audiences notice immediately, even if they can’t articulate why.

ADR Is a Tool, Not a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card

ADR is often treated as a last resort, or worse, a guaranteed solution. And unless it's a very particular, stylized choice, please don't plan to record all your movie's dialogue in ADR. People will definitely notice...

Common ADR mistakes include:

• recording ADR with a different microphone than production audio

• ignoring room acoustics and reverb

• placing ADR too cleanly in the mix

• assuming ADR can fix emotional or performance issues

Good ADR requires planning, patience, and restraint. When used intentionally, it can save a scene. When overused or rushed, it becomes one of the most noticeable post-production mistakes in indie film.

Poor Organization Is a Hidden Post-Production Killer

One of the least talked-about post-production mistakes indie filmmakers make has nothing to do with creativity, it’s organization.

Disorganized projects lead to:

• duplicated timelines

• lost versions

• unclear picture lock

• confusion during collaboration

• mistakes making it all the way to export

Clear labeling, versioning, and structured timelines aren’t busywork. They’re essential post-production tools that protect your film when deadlines tighten and stress levels rise.

Editing Mistakes: Not Cutting Enough

Many indie films run too long, not because they lack talent, but because filmmakers hesitate to cut material they worked hard to capture.

Common editing mistakes include:

• holding onto unnecessary intros

• overexplaining story beats

• refusing to remove favorite shots

• editing emotionally instead of objectively

Aggressive editing doesn’t mean careless editing. It means prioritizing the audience experience over personal attachment. One of the most valuable post-production skills an indie filmmaker can develop is knowing when to let a scene go. Every scene has to contribute to the pace of the film, and yes, your audience will notice if one doesn't.

Why Test Audiences Matter More Than You Think

Another frequent post-production mistake in indie film is skipping outside feedback.

Test audiences can reveal:

• pacing problems

• confusing story beats

• audio or visual distractions

• moments where attention drops

Even a small, informal test audience can prevent embarrassing issues from slipping through to release. Post-production isn’t just about polishing, it’s about verification.

How to Avoid Post-Production Mistakes in Indie Film

Post-production doesn’t need to be scary, it just needs to be intentional.

To avoid common post-production mistakes:

• plan for post-production during pre-production

• light for the grade you want, not the LUT you’ll use

• prioritize clean, consistent production audio

• stay organized from day one

• be ruthless in the edit

• get outside feedback before release

Indie films don’t need massive budgets to feel professional. They need clarity, discipline, and an honest understanding of what post-production can (and can’t) do.

Subscribe on YouTube